Amish Cheeses & Cheese Spreads

Our store is known for being a place to get Amish cheese and Amish cheese curds in Indianapolis area. We carry a large assortment of cheese and cheese spreads from Troyer Cheese in Ohio. Some of the flavors include:

• Bacon Cheese
• Blue Marble Cheese
• Jalapeno Muenster Cheese
• Havarti Cheese
• Bruschetta Jack Cheese
• Farmer’s Cheese
• Ranch Cheese Curds
• Garlic Dill Cheese Curds
• Smoked Cheese Curds
• Tomato Garlic Cheese Curds
• Cajun Cheese Curds
• Jalapeno Cheese Curds
• Aged Asiago Cheese Spread
• Smokey Bacon Cheese Spread
• Horseradish Cheese Spread
• Pimento Cheese Spread

Red Apple

We carry a selection of specialty cheeses from Red Apple Cheese in Chattanooga, Tennessee, including:

• Smoked Gouda
• Mango Habanero Gouda
• Green Onion Cheddar
• Horseradish Cheddar
• Pepperjack
• Smoked Cheddar

Tulip Tree Creamery

Tulip Tree Creamery is a artisinal creamery located in central Indiana, that produces internationally award winning, small batch cheeses. We carry a selection that includes:

• Fromage Frais
• Marigold
• Blazing Star
• Nightshade
• Milkweed

Viva Tia Maria

A local producer of delicious dips and spreads, we stock several of their cheese dips, including:

• White Queso Dip
• Hot Queso Dip
• Nacho Cheese Dip